.
Feedback

Updated: Palatine Gurdwara Leaders React to Wisconsin Sikh Temple Shooting

Seven people, including the shooter, are dead after a rampage during morning services in Oak Creek, WI.

Updated 6:20 p.m.: Palatine Police Commander Tom Murphy tells Patch department representatives met earlier with leaders of the Palatine Gurdwara, and patrols will be increased in the area around the clock.

Murphy said the police presence will be heightened, especially during services, but all information received so far indicate the incident was isolated, and is not a regional threat. 

Earlier: The Wisconsin Sikh Temple tragedy has reached the hearts of the Sikh religion’s brothers and sisters who belong to the Palatine Gurdwara.



“As soon as we heard [about] it, it was dreadful, heartbreaking. It is things like this that make us lose our trust, and the openness that our religion encourages fires back on us,” said Sukhdev Ghuman, president of the Palatine Gurdwara.

Ghuman said a handful of the 2,500 members who attend services at the Gurdwara went to Oak Creek earlier today to track down loved ones and offer what assistance they could to the survivors and to the families who lost someone.

“One of our members who already traveled to Wisconsin contacted his sister, and she was luckily not there during the shooting because she and her family were running late,” Ghuman said.

The entire Gurdwara prayed earlier this afternoon for those who are injured and those who lost their lives.

“These people came for peace and worship, they did not ask to die,” Ghuman said.

Ghuman said a vigil will be arranged in the coming days at the Palatine Gurdwara. The service will include special prayer sessions to draw strength from God for those who have suffered because of the murderous rampage.

Dr. Balwant Hansra, past president of the Gurdwara, said crimes against members of their religion have occurred in the past at their Palatine location.

“After 9-11, many people thought we were related to Osama bin Laden, even though their followers don’t wear turbans or beards, and we received very poor, hateful treatment because of it,” Hansra said.

In the late 1970’s, Hansra said 13 windows were broken after Ayatollah Khomeini caused unrest in Iraq. It cost the Gurdwara $2,500 per window to replace them.

“This entire incident is a shock. We believe in brotherhood, sisterhood and humanity, and pray for our brothers and sisters in Wisconsin now,” Hansra said.

Both leaders are reconsidering the food pantry that is open to everyone in light of the tragedy, out of fear for the well-being and safety of their members. 

A dispatcher for the Palatine Police Department, who did not give his name, said police have a heightened level of awareness in the area of the Gurdwara due to the Wisconsin shooting. 

Chilawyer August 7, 2012 at 04:14 am
The shooter was in the military in the mid and late 1990's, and never served overseas. PTSD not a factor here.
David Greenberg August 7, 2012 at 05:23 am
Get over yourself and stop acting so sanctimonious. America doesn't have a lock on people doing bad things. It happens all over the world, even in "Asia".
Here's some sad examples... that don't even include the insane kamikaze in WW II. How many died in the attack at Pearl Harbor? Bai Ningyang (18 yrs old) 5/8/2006 - Shiguan, China. Killed 12, injured 5 (school massacre) Wu Huanming (47 yrs old) 5/12/2010 - Linchang, China. Killed 9, injured 11 (school massacre) Kim Dae-han (56 yrs old) 2/18/2003 - Daegu, South Korea. Killed 198, injured 147 (Started subway fire. Sentenced to life). Zhang Pilin (37 yrs old) 5/7/2002 - Dalian, China. Killed 111, injured 0. Set fire to passenger cabin of an airplane (died in crash). Chen Zhengping (32 yrs old) 9/15/2002 - Nanjing, China. Killed 42, injured 300-400 (poisoning). Li Zhanin (34 yrs old) 3/29/2000 - Shajian, China. Killed 36-39, injured 30-50+ (killed by explosion he caused at a wedding). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rampage_killers
David Greenberg August 7, 2012 at 05:26 am
Unfortunately, you'll never see the lamestream media miss an opportunity to exploit something bad, while they totally ignore the good stories.
You'll hear about so-and-so shooting such-and-such over this-and-that "turf", and how so-and-so was "turning his life around"... But you'll never hear about how some criminal broke into a house, the homeowner held him at gunpoint w/o firing a shot until the police came to arrest the criminal - because depending upon your point of view it's either not sensationalist enough, or it doesn't play into the leftist agenda to disarm America...
nan August 7, 2012 at 10:10 am
sorry rick but I cant speak for what did happen in mainland china, I think you are missing the point . read the article above, again, and go from there.
nan August 7, 2012 at 10:13 am
huh?
Sully August 7, 2012 at 12:10 pm
Steve/Al/Rick and any other name you care to use, just how do you and Dan see this ad you personally being blamed? That's ridiculous. You are so blind with your dislike of so-called liberals, you can't see anything else no matter how irrational. The shooter was found to be a white supremacist and therefore his motivation was very likely to be his hatred of minorities. There is a big following in white supremacist groups, and these people feed off of the vitriol by those such as Glenn Beck, Ann Coulter, and Rush Limbaugh. That is the point. Those who are predisposed to hate and anger don't need much more to confirm their own beliefs. When you have media personalities saying " kill the liberals", whether you believe it or not, some will take that literally. I don't think there is any way that can be denied. No one on this board is directly blaming you or any other white person other than the actual shooter. The environment in which he was surrounded is the real problem.
Gary August 7, 2012 at 02:04 pm
No one has threatened you here.
I see you are just as disgusted by this discussion as I am. I will have to ask you to look the other way while we fight our little race hustling civil war. We should be discussing how everyone in the US should be free to practice their religion without fear or intimidation, and how if any of us live in fear simply because of what we believe, then none of us is really free. But, unfortunately some of us just can't let blood shed go to waste and so the rest of us have to spend time cleaning up their rhetorical mess. Last night I stood with the Palatine Sikhs in their Temple. I talk the talk, and I walk the walk.
Gary August 7, 2012 at 02:11 pm
Beck, Coulter, and Limbaugh say "kill the liberals"?
You put that in quotes, therefore you meant it literally. I have never heard that. That is exactly the kind of slander you are accusing the right of promoting. You need to educate yourself about what people on the right are actually saying. Your sources are misleading you. You are being taught to indiscriminately hate your political enemy and you are coming on here and repeating the lies you have been told. There is a technical political term for people like you. Let's just say that the leaders on the left find you to be a very useful person.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 02:51 pm
http://www.americanpolitics.com/20020205Coulter.html
http://politicalhumor.about.com/od/funnyquotes/a/anncoulter.htm http://www.onewhiteduck.com/2010/10/25/glenn-beck-says-if-you-are-a-liberal-you-probably-worship-the-devil/ Glenn Beck- "I'm thinking about killing Michael Moore, and I'm wondering if I could kill him myself, or if I would need to hire somebody to do it. ... No, I think I could. I think he could be looking me in the eye, you know, and I could just be choking the life out. Is this wrong?" (yes Glenn, that IS wrong) Gee, nothing here to stir up contempt for liberals.
Gary August 7, 2012 at 03:34 pm
It's politics. They don't have to deal with our ideas or defend their own if they can demonize and marginalize us using these tragedies as weapons. That's what's going on here. We are at the point in our history where they have no other defense than to destroy their opponents.
It's scorched-earth waste-no-crisis hard-ball politics at its worst. The good news is that they have only one card left to play, and they always play it the same way. Now that one card, the race hustle card, is a VERY powerful card and it has gone undefeated for almost 50 years. We have almost no defense against this, and the table is set up so that nearly every attempt we make to defend ourselves is twisted into more proof that we are the vile people they accuse us of being. How do you prove you don't hate without getting mad at the injustice and sounding like a hater? How do you prove you are not a racist when it is politically incorrect for a person of our color to even discuss the topic? They win the race hustle game as long as two conditions are true: 1. They can intimidate their targets into silence. 2. They get the sanction of their victims by convincing a majority of them that they are guilty of the crimes for which they have been wrongfully accused. WE are making sure #1 comes to an end right here on the Patch. But it's our refusal to accept guilt that really drives them crazy. They simply can't believe we don't see ourselves as horrible racist monsters.
GuitarMan August 7, 2012 at 03:56 pm
@ Gary.
Actually, I think in part you are making some sense. But do you see when the rhetoric from both sides is the standard stuff, the discussion doesn't move to individual responsibility? For example, though you may not agree with Rev. Wright, throwing him up to attack the president comes off shallow. Mr. Obama has done what any parent would be proud of, but imputing Rev. Wright onto Mr. Obama comes of as racist. The president is his own man. I have associated with persons that say and do things I don't completely agree with, its is unfair to conclude I accept their view completely. Would it be correct to impute on Catholics the many shortcomings of the Catholic Church? I don't think it would. I recall years ago an interview with Henry Kissinger regarding the Viet Nam War. He stated that there were “honorable positions of both side of the argument”. That what is missing today, abandon the day to day retorts that stop the discussion from moving to a point of mutual understanding and shared interest.
Gary August 7, 2012 at 04:47 pm
They drew first blood. You are addressing the wrong guy.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 06:07 pm
You accuse those of us who dont agree with you as slanderous, trying to marginalized you, as being hateful, ignorant, racist, and liars. I'd like to see some evidence for your claim. Where have I been slanderous, hateful, ignorant, and lying. Especially the lying part. I've asked others to identify my lies but no one has.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 06:08 pm
Oh, and Gary- no comments about the words of those media personalities?
GuitarMan August 7, 2012 at 06:22 pm
@ Rick Thomas.
You are not understanding my original comment. My point originally is that if like minded voices don't counter overtly inflammatory opinions, lessor equipped persons may act on the opinions, as is the case in Oak Creek. Its not about "blame" its about the integtrity of the discussion. Review a number of my comments and you'll glean my greatest concern is the course discussion prevents substantive discussion about real problems. China must be sitting back as America argues over hyperbolic assertions, while ignoring and addressing the challenges before us. Again, as Henry Kissinger said years ago there are "honorable arguments" from both sides. However, accusing our president of not being an American is not a subtantive claim rooted in fact. Please don't put up silly links that contain unsubtantiated claims. Get the bigger picture I am speaking to.
GuitarMan August 7, 2012 at 06:28 pm
Gary, your on. I would ocassionally listen to Beck to understand his rhetoric and he got bounced of FOX because he crossed the line of valid opinion versus an intent to encourage, command, or insight criminal activity. Beck IS inflammatory, but our nation needs ideas, not flame throwers.
Its never to late, to change course.
Gary August 7, 2012 at 07:23 pm
I will respond to that when you guys respond to my concerns.
I still want to know when you and the Democrat leadership are going to stop calling peaceful citizens "terrorists" and "hostage takers". I still want to know what you are going to do about the Democrat party's support for the anti-Semitic, violent, anarchic Occupy Wall Street movement which directly provided inspiration for the Sikh shooter. You guys are avoiding that. Now don't get me wrong. I am NOT blaming anyone. I just want the same answers you do. You are not to blame, but you must unilaterally solve the world's problems while the other political party undermines you in every way possible. Those are the rules, right? Be fair here. I asked when you would stop beating your wife before you asked me, so you go first. Well..... we're waiting. See how this works? Around and around we go, until you folks decide to stop the political demonization and work together to fix the real problems we face.
nan August 7, 2012 at 10:09 pm
you all are really off topic?? Is this a discussion regarding the article, or your political viewpoints are to why people do the nutty things they do??
lets get with the article here. we were targeted by a Hammerskin follower, who apprarantly kill, torture,and perform all sorts of cultish behavior to get rid of any minority group. read some of their "performances" and you will get a feel of who this man was. I can only speak of how horrible I feel for my community. we lost a persident of the Sikh temple in oak creek, and members of the sangat, as well as 4 of our temple priests and that is nothing to do with any political viewpoints.. the killer was a racist PIG thats all.. Moving forward, All we can do as Sikh Americans, is to get the word out, and HEAL. and eventually forgive with time.We would be breaking all grounds and principles of a wonderful and peaceful religion if we didnt do so. I really hope that this will teach the general public that any racial comments should not be tolerated and taken very seriouly, toward ANY group or culture, be it white, black, asian, hispancic etc.Teach your children that being of a different skin color doesnt make you any less than your neighbour down the street and theres beauty in diversity we all should live in harmony. Im very proud to say that I will continue to use the principles of Sikhism to bring people together and very proud to be a Sikh American.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 10:26 pm
Gary, you won't answer the question because you have no answer. You asked for an example and I gave you several. Also, Fox's distortion of Occupy Wall Street is just one more way they work on your anger.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 10:39 pm
Nan, I apologize for going in a direction not so specific to the article. But as you pointed out, this was an attack on "another" (meaning "not like us" to these hate groups). The argument here is some of us believe this behavior is encouraged by certain media outlets/individuals, while others see no connection and therefore believe they are being made the scape goat.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 10:42 pm
And Gary- still waiting for your proof that I'm nothing but a despicable liar.
nan August 7, 2012 at 11:11 pm
thanks sully for a good point:) and Gary I appreciate you coming together for us at the temple as you stated in one of your comments. thank you for showing us that that there can be peace.
Sully August 7, 2012 at 11:52 pm
Wow, now your name is Joe Thompson. In case you haven't noticed, your name changes on your previous posts as well. If you are attempting to make it appear there are more people on your "side", you've kind of failed. So I'll ask you too- please provide evidence that what I've said is untrue.
Walter White August 8, 2012 at 12:44 am
Ha! There are more wardrobe changes in this place than a Bette Midler show!
Nightcrawler August 8, 2012 at 08:07 am
No, just pretty much decided to stop arguing with you because you are a moron.
GuitarMan August 8, 2012 at 01:35 pm
@ Alex.
Alex my original post is not about blame; it’s about how silent white people are toward public comments political groups and individual politicians make that stoke animosity toward, for example, our president. You know the pitches, Mr. Obama wasn't born here, is Muslim, and therefore not a legitimate president. It’s political and it’s a question to conservatives; when will conservatives speak out against the unsubstantiated comments toward people of color that they are “taking the country from us”. The most distained groups discussed by conservative politicians are black welfare queens, undocumented Mexicans’, and terrorist Muslims (anyone Arab in appearance). It’s not rocket science, just common sense, words have consequences.
GuitarMan August 8, 2012 at 01:43 pm
Yeah, I'm getting replies from some new commetors, but the link doesn't come back to that name. How many alias are some folks using?
Sully August 8, 2012 at 01:46 pm
So right now he's Alex. You know, every time I ask someone to prove me a liar, instead I get a personal attack (such as being called a moron, per Alex, or whatever choice of name he's using at the time). "Alex", I'm really curious as to why you've changed your name four or five times in the same string of comments.
GuitarMan August 8, 2012 at 01:53 pm
@ Gary & Joe Thompson.
I think you are the new and improved "Joe Thompson". If not please advise. Mr. Thompson one of your responses to me is: "I recall several occasions during the D46 school debates and other posts where you were blatantly making racist comments. Others pointed them out specifically in the past, too." However, I have not ever made racist comments toward anyone on this blog. On the other hand, I do call out white people for their apparent ignorance as to how words about other ethnic groups have consequences, and as I've stated in this thread I believe the Oak Creek matter is one example of the consequences. As a side note in no way do I believe this is a second amendment issue, just in case you are tempted to veer of into another topic.
GuitarMan August 8, 2012 at 02:13 pm
@ Alex Stevens.
Come on, name calling? Take this to heart Alex, if you were in grade school, you'd be scolded for resorting to name calling. I don't agree with all comments, but calling someone a "mouron" is more like taking your ball and going home. To much heat, then get out of the kitchen, but don't sulk if you are unwilling to answer a question.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Niles-Morton Grove Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Pam DeFiglio (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 10:08 pm
Hi Comment Guy, Thanks for asking! I was finding that we would get a lot of people guessing forRead More some restaurants (usually when there was a payoff of free pizza), and not very many people entering for other restaurants. Do you think we should bring them back? I'm open to people's opinions. --Pam
Comment Guy June 13, 2013 at 11:33 pm
Hi Pam,
Comment Guy June 13, 2013 at 11:35 pm
Hi Pam, Yes, I thought it would be great if we brought it back. For me personally, whenever I wouldRead More seed the contest on my Twitter timeline, I would immediately go to the site. And if there is an offer of free food even better. It does not even necessarily be a restaurant as it can also be any other type of business, i.e., bakery, retail, gym, car services, etc.
Pam DeFiglio (Editor) June 4, 2013 at 03:31 pm
It starts Friday, June 7 at 4pm and continues through Sunday June 9. Free hot dogs, free breakfastRead More Saturday, chances to win an iPad mini, lots of fun things for adults and kids. Plus, of course, the summer reading program.
Niles Public Library June 4, 2013 at 03:39 pm
Click here for day-to-day activities throughout the weekend:Read More http://library.booksite.com/6392/nl/?list=CNL1&group=EB138 Hope to see you there!