.
Feedback

Decoding Obama, Romney Health Plans

A health insurance attorney explains some of what the two presidential candidates said in Wednesday's debate.

 

When President Obama and Republican nominee talked about insurance during the debate last Wednesday, some of us may have needed just a little background.

Brad Burd, J.D., general counsel at GoHealthInsurance.com, a Chicago-based purveyor of insurance plans, explains some of what they were talking about. The attached infographic helps spell it out too. You can also see it a little more close-up here. 

Q. Romney and Obama talked a little about how Obamacare and Romneycare would affect people who are on the verge of retirement (age 62-65) and also how it would affect people about a decade younger, (age 53-55). Could you enlighten us on that?

Brad Burd: A key difference between the Medicare plans of the two candidates has to do with the manner in which health care providers receive payment.

The current system of payment that President Obama would keep in place is one where the government pays health care providers directly for medical services received by Medicare beneficiaries.

Governor Romney would like to introduce a “premium support” payment system. Premium support is the paying out of cash to Medicare beneficiaries so that they can buy their own health insurance from a private insurance company.

Under Romney’s plan, the premium support model would not be implemented until 2023. This means that no one currently over the age of 55 would see any changes to the Medicare they receive now or expect to receive in the near future.

During the debate, Governor Romney stated that $716 billion would be cut from Medicare programs under the Affordable Care Act. Is this true?

Burd: This is true according to the most recent estimate from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) for the period of 2013-2022.

The question is – how will this affect Medicare beneficiaries directly? The planned Medicare cuts are portioned out in the following manner: A third of the cut will come out of reduced reimbursements to hospitals. Another third comes out of cutting down overpayments to insurance companies offering Medicare Advantage. The rest of the estimated $716 billion will come from eliminating reimbursements to a wide range other healthcare providers.

Of the $716 billion, there are technically no cuts to Medicare benefits. Does this mean that it still could happen? It’s all speculation at this point. Cuts to Medicare could lead to cuts in quality of care down the road. 

Some Medicare Advantage beneficiaries are particularly concerned that lower payments from the government could result in a decrease in the amount of Medicare Advantage benefits their private insurance company will provide.

Another concern Romney brought up during the debate is that doctors and hospitals may just completely cease providing care to Medicare-covered patients, because, after the cuts, the government will cover fewer of the expenses charged.

How would Obama's plan and Romney's plan affect owners of small and medium-sized businesses, particularly in regards to providing health insurance for their employees?

Burd: Both candidates share a desire to encourage small business growth. The topic of health reform and small business is a different story.

President Obama’s Affordable Care Act requires large businesses (defined as those with 50 or more full-time employees) to provide health insurance or face a penalty. Businesses with fewer than 50 employees are exempt from this provision entirely. However, if a small business (under 25 full-time employees) wants to provide health insurance to its employees, they may be eligible for a small business tax credit.

Governor Romney is against a federal-based health insurance mandate for businesses of any size and does not support financial penalties for businesses that do not comply.

No matter who wins the election, I think we will see a marked increase in the number of businesses deciding to open a Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA). These IRS sanctioned arrangements are established as a way to reimburse employees (tax free) for their out-of-pocket medical expenses and health insurance premiums. An employer completely funds the account and sets clear parameters for what medical costs the HRA will reimburse employees for. HRAs do not “rollover” once an individual becomes employed somewhere else.

What does the election mean for the future of Americans with pre-existing conditions?

Burd: Regardless of who is elected, the Affordable Care Act has already been passed and likely will go into full effect as planned in 2014. Therefore, pre-existing conditions will indeed be covered.

If elected, Governor Romney definitely has plans to repeal and change health care reform. While he has not provided any specifics about his plan, he has publicly stated that he would keep the pre-existing conditions provision intact.

D'skidoc October 9, 2012 at 11:38 am
He said he would keep the pre-existing condition provision intact, but will make it impossible for any state to do what MA did by cutting federal Medicare reimbursement. It was calculated that the difference could mean 50 million less people with insurance coverage than with the enactment of Obamacare.
Cynthia Schafer October 9, 2012 at 12:21 pm
He said the pre-existing coverage clause would not be mandated. He thinks the insurance companies and the marketplace will take care of it. seeing as how they were still excluding this up to the last minute, I don't believe it will work without a mandate.
Carol Kraines October 9, 2012 at 12:49 pm
To be clear - Romney said his plan will mandate covering people with pre existing conditions ONLY if they have current health insurance. It will not force insurance companies to cover new clients with pre existing conditions. So his statement is a bit of a con.
Gary October 9, 2012 at 02:34 pm
To mandate that "insurance" companies cover people with pre-existing conditions is to change the concept of an insurance company into a forced welfare distributor. The only way it could possibly work in a free market sense is to allow insurance companies to pool those people into extremely high risk groups, and then set very high prices on those policies.
The issue of pre-existing medical conditions is a very difficult one, but driving insurance companies into bankruptcy is not the solution.
RB October 9, 2012 at 02:50 pm
At some point, Romney has said he would leave it to the States to cover the Pre-existing conditions. States already have high risk pools and they are unaffordable. Romney's approach in Mass. is nearly the same as Obamacare. Yes, it is a State and not the entire country but unless the Federal Government mandates coverage the way Mitt did in Mass, we'll have some progressive States with coverage and others with no coverage. It's all in to make it work.
GuitarMan October 9, 2012 at 09:29 pm
@Gary.
Give me an update on when insurance companies are driven into bankruptcy. The problem is in America we pay nearly double and the outcomes are not better, read on. Pile on that fraud and you may begin to see the problem. My wife has spent 20+ years in long term care and reported or testified on fraud. I've worked in big pharma and seen similar abuses. Its much more than your think, in the order of 700 billion over X years, which is what both candidates have targeted for cuts.
GuitarMan October 9, 2012 at 09:33 pm
I don't want to seem cynical, but if you follow the money you'll see where the problem is. In both Massachusetts and on the Federal level, its about the money and who is getting it, people or companies.
For an enlightened look at insurance, research the anti-trust waiver given the industry decades ago, and why.
Guido McGinty October 9, 2012 at 09:35 pm
"Give me an update on when insurance companies are driven into bankruptcy."
Insurance companies will make a lot more money under Barrycare than they would without it. The Total State spent around half of all health care dollars before Barrycare was passed. Is it any wonder that the price of said health care is spiraling upwards? (See also, higher education) I must say I was impressed with your copy and paste skills on prior articles, Geeeeetarman. Not every two bit leftist knows how to use ctrl-c and ctrl-v.
McCloud October 9, 2012 at 09:54 pm
Unaffordable? The rates for the IL pre-ex plans are very reasonable compared to market. IPXP.com shows the rates, without liberal blog BS.
McCloud October 9, 2012 at 09:56 pm
There are many insurance companies that are unable to operate at 80% loss ratio mandates. So they get out of the market, and you get the too big to fail routine for a few carriers.
McCloud October 9, 2012 at 10:52 pm
American ideals accrording to some liberal goof, it's all in to make it work. Read the Constitutional pal.
D'skidoc October 10, 2012 at 12:50 am
Not that I have anything against rich insurance executives, but if you take the insurace (read redistribution of health care dollars) industry out of health care the cost immediately goes down from about 14% to 11% of GDP. What a savings we could get by just killing health insurance entirely. Very few getting rich at the expense of the health of the country. Thats the GOP way.
RB October 10, 2012 at 01:18 am
Mac, those rates are associated with the Affordable Care Act which Romney says he will do away with his first day in office. He has said nothing about affordability of Pre existing state insurance.
Maria Smith October 11, 2012 at 09:52 am
Romney wants to introduce a "premium support" method of paying health care providers for Medicare. Beneficiaries would receive vouchers to purchase their own insurance through private insurers. This plan would not go into effect until 2023. No citizen currently over the age of 55 would see any changes to the Medicare they receive or expect to receive.
http://speedyloansearch.com/
D'skidoc October 11, 2012 at 11:37 am
Over 55 when? i just hit the double nickel. Am I safe? I guess my younger sister, will have to shell out bongo bucks for her medicare ( I mean insurance). A $6K stipend won't get close to covering the premium now. Imagine in 20 or 30 years when your yearly premium hits 6 figures?
D'skidoc October 11, 2012 at 11:42 am
btw? is this the "severely conservative" Romney, or the one who just completely made up new more centrist positions last week? Ryan is going to have a tough time 'splainin' how his 35 anti-abortion bills in the House square up to the general electorate.
Sergey Kemskiy October 12, 2012 at 11:13 am
I must confess that your writing on taxation is impressive. Issues regarding taxation and IRS are crucial for every business, that is why it is important to have a contact of a good tax lawyer. That is why I am trying to create the directory of the best US tax attorneys with detailed description of their legal practice. For example, look a category related to Illinois http://attorney-online.info/dir/tax/illinois/909 You must be a good tax attorney. If you are, you should submit your contacts to the attorney directory.
Sergey Kemskiy October 12, 2012 at 11:13 am
I must confess that your writing on taxation is impressive. Issues regarding taxation and IRS are crucial for every business, that is why it is important to have a contact of a good tax lawyer. That is why I am trying to create the directory of the best US tax attorneys with detailed description of their legal practice. For example, look a category related to Illinois http://attorney-online.info/dir/tax/illinois/909 You must be a good tax attorney. If you are, you should submit your contacts to the attorney directory
Sergey Kemskiy October 12, 2012 at 11:14 am
I must confess that your writing on taxation is impressive. Issues regarding taxation and IRS are crucial for every business, that is why it is important to have a contact of a good tax lawyer. That is why I am trying to create the directory of the best US tax attorneys with detailed description of their legal practice. For example, look a category related to Illinois http://attorney-online.info/dir/tax/illinois/909 You must be a good tax attorney. If you are, you should submit your contacts to the directory
awreerhst December 26, 2012 at 03:02 am
http://www.coachoutletonlinebfd.com/ Coach Outlet Online
http://www.guccibeltstb.com/ Gucci Belts http://www.coachoutletonlineyds.net/ Coach Factory Online

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Niles-Morton Grove Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Pam DeFiglio (Editor) June 13, 2013 at 10:08 pm
Hi Comment Guy, Thanks for asking! I was finding that we would get a lot of people guessing forRead More some restaurants (usually when there was a payoff of free pizza), and not very many people entering for other restaurants. Do you think we should bring them back? I'm open to people's opinions. --Pam
Comment Guy June 13, 2013 at 11:33 pm
Hi Pam,
Comment Guy June 13, 2013 at 11:35 pm
Hi Pam, Yes, I thought it would be great if we brought it back. For me personally, whenever I wouldRead More seed the contest on my Twitter timeline, I would immediately go to the site. And if there is an offer of free food even better. It does not even necessarily be a restaurant as it can also be any other type of business, i.e., bakery, retail, gym, car services, etc.
Pam DeFiglio (Editor) June 4, 2013 at 03:31 pm
It starts Friday, June 7 at 4pm and continues through Sunday June 9. Free hot dogs, free breakfastRead More Saturday, chances to win an iPad mini, lots of fun things for adults and kids. Plus, of course, the summer reading program.
Niles Public Library June 4, 2013 at 03:39 pm
Click here for day-to-day activities throughout the weekend:Read More http://library.booksite.com/6392/nl/?list=CNL1&group=EB138 Hope to see you there!